• Inicio
  • Quiénes somos
    • ¿Qué es Eben?
    • Congresos Anuales
    • Miembros
    • Junta Directiva
    • ¿Cómo hacerse socio?
  • Opinión
    • En pocas palabras
    • Nuestros socios opinan
  • Noticias
  • Eventos
    • Eventos Eben
    • Otros Eventos
  • Recursos
    • Material docente
    • Publicaciones científicas
    • Hemeroteca
  • Sitios de interés
    • Webs de ética empresarial
    • Blogs
    • Twitter
  • Contacto

EBEN

  • Inicio
  • Quiénes somos
    • ¿Qué es Eben?
    • Congresos Anuales
    • Miembros
    • Junta Directiva
    • ¿Cómo hacerse socio?
  • Opinión
    • En pocas palabras
    • Nuestros socios opinan
  • Noticias
  • Eventos
    • Eventos Eben
    • Otros Eventos
  • Recursos
    • Material docente
    • Publicaciones científicas
    • Hemeroteca
  • Sitios de interés
    • Webs de ética empresarial
    • Blogs
    • Twitter
  • Contacto
En pocas palabrasOpinión

Firma invitada: Chris Cowton

by admin 10 de octubre de 20164 de diciembre de 2018
10 de octubre de 20164 de diciembre de 2018

Do we research the right things?

firma-invitadaThe amount of academic research being conducted and published on business ethics has expanded greatly. I believe this is a good thing. However, such is the importance of business and the ethical challenges that it faces, our work as academics will never be done. There will always be a need for further research – of course! In fact, impressive though the advances have been, the business ethics scholarly community is still small compared to many cognate areas, whether they be academic disciplines (such as economics) or particular fields within management (such as marketing). Our capacity is still very limited when set against what needs to be done, so we need to be wise about how we allocate our scarce resources. A piece of research might be of some value, but does it come at a high opportunity cost?

Indeed, when I reflect on what is published, I worry about where we focus our efforts. To pick one example, why was there so little research on the ethics of finance before 2007? Surely finance was not considered unimportant or believed to entail no ethical issues. (If that was the case, I don’t think many people hold that view now.)

I don’t want to attempt to explain why, as an academic community, we had a blind spot regarding the ethics of finance. Nor do I wish to attempt to list all the topics and issues that I think we should be researching. Rather, I would like to take a step back and identify some of the factors that can influence our choice of research focus and highlight some of the risks if a particular factor becomes too dominant.

So what might those influences be? As researchers, many of our strongest influences are academic. One of the most obvious, familiar to any PhD student, is previous literature. It is important to be aware of what has been written before, and authors often make suggestions for further research at the end of their papers. Yet if we take cues exclusively from previous research, we risk moving in ever-decreasing circles, writing “footnotes to footnotes”, of interest only to the protagonists involved in that particular conversation.

Many of us also look to other academic disciplines, where developments can influence our research. A good example from philosophy is the revival of virtue ethics, which has now been profitably taken up in business ethics. However, although developments in academic disciplines might suggest fruitful avenues, they are probably more important for how we do our research – the ways in which we look at and investigate the world – than for what we actually research.

Still other business ethicists might look to developments in business and management research, which itself is subject to influence by academic disciplines. Such research is likely to provide stronger cues for the content of our research than might academic disciplines themselves. Indeed, it might be particularly pertinent for business ethicists to subject new topics to ethical scrutiny as they develop. Not only would this help ethical aspects to enter the debates early on, but addressing fashionable areas might open up opportunities for ethics in the classroom as teachers look for material to help them cover new topics.

This brings me to my fourth academic influence: the curriculum. What we teach in the classroom, including subjects other than business ethics (I was a Professor of Accounting until recently), can prompt ideas about research that we could undertake. Given the importance of integrating ethics into the curriculum and the huge numbers of students who study mainstream business and management subjects, research that is easily related to the curriculum is of immense potential value.

Finally, much research is influenced by the resources available, such as datasets and research tools. This can lead to a position where what is researched is what is possible, or even easy, to do, rather than what is important. I confess that I sometimes have this feeling, for example, when I contemplate what a large proportion of research on socially responsible investment is concerned with its financial performance.

So far I have only been considering academic influences, but we are talking about business ethics and that prompts the question of what sort of influence the world outside the academy should have on our research; “more than it does at present”, would be a common response. This is part of a more general debate that is very familiar in the world of business schools.

One source of ideas for what we should research is managers themselves, perhaps systematically through surveys or more anecdotally through contacts we have. However, we should be influenced not just by the concerns of business but also by concerns about business, whether those emanate from stakeholder groups or from a more holistic societal or ecological perspective.

I am sure that readers of this piece (if any have got this far!) can expand on my list and provide richer insights into the particular factors I have identified. However, my aim will have been achieved if you reflect upon the influences to which your own choices of research project are subject and use that process of reflection to check whether your research priorities should be confirmed or realigned. What factors lead you to research what you research? Are some stronger or weaker than they should be? And how might they work together to produce a research agenda in which you can take pride – not (just) for how well the research is conducted or how prestigious is the journal you publish in, but because it addresses questions that matter.

Of course, the influences I’ve identified don’t affect us directly and unambiguously; they are filtered in all sorts of ways. This will be the case in any academic field. However, as business ethicists, perhaps we should be particularly aware of having an obligation to think carefully about what we should research. I hope you agree and find these few thoughts helpful. However, if no reader does find this piece helpful, I realise that I am impaled upon my own analysis; I should have devoted my time to something of more value! However, I live in hope that this is not the case.

If you are interested in what I have written here, you might like to look at the following two pieces:

  • Cowton, C.J. (2008), ‘On setting the agenda for business ethics research’, in C. Cowton & M. Haase (Eds), Trends in Business and Economic Ethics (Berlin: Springer) 11-30.
  • Campbell, D. & C.J. Cowton (2015), ‘Method issues in business ethics research: finding credible answers to questions that matter’, Business Ethics: A European Review, 24 (S1) S3-S10.

Christopher J. Cowton was, from 1996, Professor of Accounting and then, from 2008, also Dean of the Business School at the University of Huddersfield. He recently stepped down as Dean, taking the title of Professor of Financial Ethics. He may be contacted at c.j.cowton@hud.ac.uk.

0 comentarios
0
FacebookTwitterLinkedinWhatsapp

Dejar un comentario Cancel Reply

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Al utilizar este formulario, usted acepta el almacenamiento y el manejo de sus datos en este sitio web.

Twitter

EbenspainFollow

Avatar
Retweet on TwitterEbenspain Retweeted
AvatarCIDAF-UCM@cidaf_ucm·
21 Feb

XXX CONGRESO EBEN – Ética y Sostenibilidad: un binomio necesario en el logro de los ODS (8-9 junio 2023. Cádiz) @Ebenspain @IsabelRMora https://cidafucm.es/spip.php?article45372

Reply on Twitter 1628079632040833037Retweet on Twitter 16280796320408330371Like on Twitter 16280796320408330371Twitter 1628079632040833037
Retweet on TwitterEbenspain Retweeted
AvatarGEAccounting@GEAccounting·
23 Feb

#monetizarvalorsocial #socialaccounting #stakeholder @uclm_es #RSE #sostenibilidad @upvehu #JLRetolaza @GEAccounting @LeireSanJose Un placer!

Reply on Twitter 1628605616708022273Retweet on Twitter 16286056167080222734Like on Twitter 16286056167080222737Twitter 1628605616708022273
AvatarEbenspain@Ebenspain·
21 Feb

Calle for Papers open: Cádiz #ethic #stakeholder #virtue #Marketing #EticsinFinance #csr #RSE #sostenibilidad #tesis #premios https://www.eben-spain.org/call-for-papers-xxx-congreso-eben-espana/
Envía ahora tu ponencia o proyecto. ¡Puede ser premiado!

Reply on Twitter 1627896573827989509Retweet on Twitter 16278965738279895093Like on Twitter 16278965738279895093Twitter 1627896573827989509

Categorías

  • Destacado (18)
  • En pocas palabras (56)
  • Eventos (114)
  • Eventos Eben (52)
  • Material docente (76)
  • Noticias de Ética Empresarial (278)
  • Nuestros socios opinan (188)
  • Opinión (220)
  • Otros Eventos (84)
  • Recursos (294)

RSS Agustin Domingo

  • De Bergoglio a Francisco
  • Presentación Homo Curans, U.P. Comillas, 8 febrero 2023
  • Presentación HOMO CURANS en CEU Colomina 8 de marzo de 2023

RSS Antonio Argandoña

  • La sociedad civil (I)
  • Para ejercitar la paciencia
  • Para qué sirven las virtudes

RSS Begoña Sánchez Ramos

  • BEGOÑA SÁNCHEZ-RAMOS, PRESIDENTA DE ACROSS INTERNACIONAL, MEDALLA DE ORO AL MÉRITO EN EL TRABAJO Y POR SU COMPROMISO CON LA GESTIÓN DE LOS DERECHOS HUMANOS EN LA EMPRESA
  • “Empresa con enfoque de Derechos Humanos (DDHH). ¿Cómo lograrlo? Un camino a recorrer por las empresas españolas”
  • Articulo de Begoña Sánchez Ramos publicado en InCOMPLIANCE Revista corporativa de International Compliance Association (ICA) asks how companies can achieve a corporate focus on human rights

RSS Joan Fontrodona

  • Tiempo de prioridades
  • Conservar el planeta, pero… ¿para quién?
  • Etica e Inteligencia Artificial

RSS Edita Olaizola

  • Un coach abejorro
  • Antropocentrismo y ética
  • ¡Viva la atención al cliente!

Eventos EBEN

  • CALL FOR PAPERS FOR THE 15TH RAMON LLULL JOURNAL OF APPLIED ETHICS

    20 de marzo de 2023
  • “Call for papers”. XXX Congreso EBEN-España

    27 de enero de 2023
  • “Call for papers” XXIX Congreso presencial EBEN España 2022

    22 de febrero de 2022

Otros eventos

  • Call for papers for the 21th IESE International Symposium on Ethics, Business and Society

    18 de noviembre de 2020
  • Call for papers for the 27th International Vincentian Business Ethics Conference

    2 de abril de 2020
  • Society for Business Ethics – Annual Conference 2020

    14 de diciembre de 2019

Opinión

  • En pocas palabras: La ética es rentable…y en tiempos de pandemia más

    22 de abril de 2021
  • Firma invitada: Sandra Mª Sánchez

    22 de abril de 2021
  • Reconectar lo social en la ética de la empresa

    22 de abril de 2021

Noticias

  • Why Working From Home Might Promote More Ethical

    22 de abril de 2021
  • El sector hotelero apuesta por la economía circular para superar la crisis de la covid-19

    22 de abril de 2021
  • Adela Cortina: “la empresa del futuro será ética, social, verde o no será”

    22 de abril de 2021

Contacta

Twitter Linkedin

Eben Spain

  • ¿Qué es Eben?
  • Congresos Anuales
  • Los miembros de EBEN
  • La Junta Directiva de EBEN
  • ¿Cómo hacerse socio?
  • Newsletter
  • Contacto
  • Aviso Legal

Contenidos

  • En pocas palabras
  • Nuestros socios opinan
  • Noticias de Ética Empresarial
  • Eventos Eben
  • Otros Eventos
  • Material docente
  • Publicaciones científicas
  • Sitios de interés

Hermanos Aguirre, 2
48014 Bilbao


info@eben-spain.org

@2019 - EBEN Spain - Designed by Prestigia